For this week’s blog, I was asked to observe an
interaction between an adult and a child communicating. Since most of my time
is spent behind the toddler/two year-old doors, I decided to observe in the
preschool class.
The encounter I observed was between the teacher and a
five year-old girl, both standing on the porch looking onto the playground. I
heard the child ask her teacher why the rain boots that were inside a plastic
bin, always stayed out on the porch. The teacher looked at the child, and said;
“I don’t know, I guess because they are muddy”. The child looked up at the
teacher and said;” last week they were clean, how did they get dirty? Was it
from being out here?” The teacher looked down at the child, and pushed at her
shoulder, “we did an activity, the day you were absent” she then told the child
to find an area to play in. In this week’s media segment, Lisa Kolebeck
philosophy in regards to communicating with children is as follows; “Sensitivity,
respect, acceptance, reflective listening, and providing the space for each
child to be her unique self” (Laureate Education, 2011).
The teacher displayed a lack of respect, by providing short answers to the
child’s questions, there was also a lack of sensitivity displayed by the
teacher when she told the child that she missed an activity, while using the “muddy”
boots, when the child missed a day at school. It was clear the child was
interested and concerned about the “muddy” boots. And from observing the child’s
non-verbal cue, as she was pushed away, seemed sad, disappointed, lost, and
lonely.
During my observation, I first could not help but to
think, how much dialoguing could have happened between the child and the
teacher, even in such a brief one on one moment. Even if there was no
communication between the two, the teacher could have helped the child by
helping her to engage in an outdoor activity. As the child asked the teacher the first
question, the teacher seemed as if she did not want to be bothered. After the
child stated that the boots were clean the week before, at that point the
teacher could have reversed the conversation, making it more inviting, by
asking open-ended questions, about the “mysterious muddy” boots.
The end of the observation for me was after the final
comment made to the child, that there was an activity that took place using the
boots, when the child was not at school, as well as pushing the child off,
telling her to find a place a play.” Sociocultural theories suggest the power of
language to convey and construct meaning. Because Language has cultural and psychological
functions communicating and thinking—teachers' words and the way they use them create
meaning for children as well as for themselves” (Mercer, 1995).
Children are often interested and curious about things
in their environment. In this particular scenario, the class generally takes
hikes on a certain day of the week. The young girl that stood beside her
teacher was absent the day of the hike, due to a fever. What particularly made
this hike day special, was the amount of rain, and mud accumulated, making for
not only a hike day, but mud day! As the educator receiving this child’s
questions, I would first come down to the child’s level, so that she will know
I am listening. I would use patience in trying to help find an answer for her
questions, and involve the child in the conversation about the hike days she
was able to participate in, to ensure that yes, you missed that day on the
hike, but there are more to come, as well as more opportunities, for a mud a
mud day.
Reference:
Laureate Education, Inc. (2011). Strategies
for working with diverse children: Communicating with young children.
Baltimore, MD: Author
Rainer Dangei, J., & Durden, T. R. (2010). The nature of teacher talk during small group activities. YC: Young Children, 65(1), 74-81. Retrieved from the Walden Library using the Education Research Complete database. http://ezp.waldenulibrary.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=ehh&AN=47964033&site=ehost-live&scope=site
Cynthia,
ReplyDeleteGreat observation! In a previous class, I interviewed a Pre-school teacher mentioned the most effective way to communicate with children is by getting down to their level. I am pleased to see you both share the same key factors in how to effectively communicate with young children. Communicating positively with young children helps them to develop confidence, feelings of self-worth, and healthy relationship with others.
Hi Cynthia,
ReplyDeleteExcellent observation! I too would have been disappointed in the teacher's response to the child and her lack of enthusiasm to support and engage the child's curiosity. The teacher could have engaged the child's imagination by stating: "I wonder how the boots got mud on them. Do you have any thoughts on how the boots got mud on them?" The child would've had a positive interaction with her teacher and moved on to the next activity happily.
Hello Cynthia,
ReplyDeleteA lack of respect hinders communication between children and teachers. When a child wants to share a favorite moment and/or interest; they goal is to exchange ideas with someone who is kind and friendly. Yet, there comes a point when an educator is not willing to take time to have a conversation with the child. They may feel that the child is talking non-sense and etc. This type of strategy leads for the child to feel not important. By feeling not important could lead to social difficulties later in life. I find this applicable for all ages. “We leave ourselves open to surprises, because children have so many surprises inside we can learn about it if we're quiet enough to let them come to us with it.” (Laureate Education, Inc., 2011).
Tanya Terrell
Reference
Laureate Education, Inc. (2011). Strategies for Working with Diverse Children: Communicating with Young Children. Baltimore, MD: Author.